This was number 1 on our pasty tour of 2022. My husband and I are going back to the UP for vacation and cannot wait to eat their delicious pasty. Great buttery, thin and flaky pie crust and their beef had an excellent taste.
We made it back in Sept 2023 for more pasties from Toni's Country Kitchen! They did not disappoint. I would stay in the Keewanaw the entire time just for Toni's pasties.
Toni's is the large and delicious pasty on the right compared to Jen's that was in some need of salt and pepper.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pasty
A number 1!!
Homey, cozy, quaint, small towny.
First found out about this place from the now defunct ‘Gourmet Magazine’. The author had written about his summers on the Keweenaw. And this place got a mention. The article fired my imagination and I made it a point to come up here. Now, it took 20 years between reading the article, and getting my butt here. Totally worth the trip. As soon as I got off the plane, I straight lined right over. I was starvin’ like Marvin.
Got the eggs, ham, potatoes, and the optional onions. And those onions were super oniony, just how I like them. Also grabbed 5 or 6 pasties to go: what I’d really come for. I’d rented a cabin in the woods, on the lake. Wanted enough pasties to last a few days. Having them on hand sure beat having to eat out or cook every meal.
Highly recommend. Don’t pass this place up if you’re in the area.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
What a great place to eat! My wife and I ordered breakfast for dinner. She had the cinnamon French toast with bacon and I had full stack of pancakes with sausage links.
The service was above board. Ella was a whirlwind. She was the only one taking orders and clearing tables and did it with a smile. Great attitude and love the old time diner atmosphere. Will be returning in the near future.
