Taste dishes of Italian cuisine at this pizzeria. Nicely cooked garlic pizza, chicken wings and philly cheese steaks can make a profound impression on you. Try good strawberry cheesecakes and tasty chocolate cakes to form your opinion about Brooklyn Heights. You will hardly forget delicious draft beer, martinis or margaritas that you can degust. Great lemonade gets positive reviews. This place with takeout food is suitable for those visitors who like to have supper on the go. The success of this spot would be impossible without the creative staff. Fast service is something that people note in their reviews. You will like reasonable prices. The spectacular atmosphere is what this pizzeria is about. The average rating of Brooklyn Heights on Google is 4.2.
Heads up. $10.00 for bread. $8.00 for a SIDE salad. Insane
I just copied and pasted from Mandola in Cedar Park's menu "GARLIC BREAD ⩔ $5.5
Add Mozzarella $1.5"
Seriously, go look! Just can not do it anymore.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 2
They serve pies on the softer side, which is why it was dismaying that mine ended up underbaked (almost doughy in the middle).
But the cheese and toppings were really nice, so I tried to bake them longer in my Ninja, but I ended up making a big melted mess.
I called and told them what happened, and "Conner" was polite and helpful, and had two more pies made for me right away.
That's all a pizza joint needs to do, to earn 5 stars in my book. The pizza tastes good.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pizza
7/11 pizza is more consistently tasty. Sure you can get a cool big slice of pizza. For the price of a whole pizza at anywhere else. But then they don’t even have friendly or helpful staff. You’ll ask for a side you requested only to be met with rudeness. And then they won’t get your sides or ranch etc. confused as to how they’re still operating.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Atmosphere: 4
Seemed like a nice place. I ordered a slice to go. I watched the orders as they were put up and finally had to ask one of the wait staff to check on my order. He grabbed a pizza box that had been setting in the window for at least 15 minutes. I took my order and checked it out. It was barely warm. I stormed out and vowed never to return. Horrible service. Everyone was in such a hurry to clean up and close but nobody paying attention to orders coming up. It might be a nice place to dine in but don’t order anything to go, you’ll wait forever for mediocre food. Never again for me.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 1
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 4
This was our first time trying Brooklyn Heights Pizza, we stopped in at the Lakeline location on a Thursday evening. The place was a bit crowded, but we were seated immediately.
Maddie was our server, she was awesome, attentive but not intrusive. Thanks Maddie!
We started with the chicken wings … medium buffalo style sauce, and they were excellent. Perfect balance of heat on the wings, and the wings were fried crispy, just how we like them! The celery and blue cheese on the side were a nice complement to the wings.
We split the large Greek salad, which was full of quality ingredients. Nice size for two people to split. The Greek dressing appeared homemade, it was delicious! (if it's not homemade, please share the brand! LOL)
We tried two pizzas, the margarita pizza with pepperoni added, and the combo pizza with onion added. Both pizzas were outstanding! We are pretty tough critics when it comes to pizza, but we have to say that the pizza at Brooklyn Heights pizza is some of the best we’ve had in the Leander/Cedar Park area. The crust is nice, edges crunchy and soft, the middle crust stiff enough to hold the ingredients and a nice "chew" factor. The cornmeal dusting was perfect!
BHP, thanks for a great meal! We were a bit hesitant to try BHP, because of some of the low ratings from reviewers, but we're sure glad we did! We will definitely be back!
Update October 25, 2023
Ordered delivery tonight from BHP (after another local place messed up delivery). The food was delivered quickly, and consistent with all of our other experiences at BHP, the food was great, even delivered (this was out first time ordering for delivery).
We ordered wings and 2 Greek salads as starters, both were deelish! The wings were simple wings, no breading, no frills, just plumb wings fried crisp and tossed in a medium heat buffalo-style hot sauce. When it comes to great wings, simple is king! The Greek salads were a bit on the small side, but the ingredients were super fresh and the dressing was wonderful.
Two pizzas followed ... one was our creation of meats and veggies, the other was the house "American Cheeseburger" pizza. Both pizzas were very good. All ingredients (again) very fresh, and generous portions piled on the pies. We ordered large sizes to have leftovers, which were equally delicious when warmed in the oven the next day. We really like BHP, highly recommend!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
We were grabbing lunch when going out. We ordered a medium veggie pizza. It was pretty good, but I felt like the cheese dominated the flavor, I sort of couldn’t taste the sauce much either. There was also quite a lot of oil on it making it hard to eat. The veggies were fine. Overall all I could taste was oil and cheese. I don’t know about the other dishes at Brooklyn Heights Pizzeria, but the veggie pizza was not so good.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
